After years of hemming, hawing, and procrastinating, I have finally pulled the trigger on some current level macro equipment. I evaluated every possible permutation of equipment and decided on the following setup;
Body: Canon T3i
Lens: Canon 100mm macro
Evaluated prior to pulling trigger:and
Full frame digital
Micro 4/3
P&S
Film and transparency
I will explore reasoning as to why all other avenues were shut down so that you can learn from my analysis.
I wanted this to be a continuing experiment, thus it didn't make sense to start out with the best possible solutions, nor the most expensive. While I had made the pilgrimage to B&H photo
www.bhphoto.com in early May to try my hand at the newest full frame Canon 6D and the Nikon equivalent, spending a couple of grand plus lenses while in the experimental phase seemed a bit much.
After reading a lot of material
www.photomacrography.net and
dpreview.comon the potential benefits of the APS-C or "cropped" sensor, it was decided that at least FF could be ruled out. The cropped sensor will evidently provide greater reach, and narrow down the angle of view for a particular focal length. My new 100mm macro lens will actually provide a focal length much like a 150mm lens. With a more restricted angle (about 8 degrees less) at the same distance from the subject, it seems like the elimination of background material would be a benefit of using this sensor size.
Micro 4/3 was a very tempting route to take. The technology is great, the ability to use legacy glass (non 4/3), and there was a lot of back and forth on this subject. The Wifi interface is there, and it's a great all purpose solution for anyone wanting to change lenses in the field. My reason for not using this method was purely financial. I'm still taking baby steps, and spending 1K for a body alone, that may not work out seemed a bit steep. Part of my reasoning being if I could buy both components to further the experiment for 1K, if it didn't work out, the most I would lose would be a couple of hundred bucks.
Using P&S has been a less than satisfactory method of pursuing this endeavor, as the backgrounds were always distracting, the approach to the subject essentially covered it, and frankly, with my older hands, the camera just was too miniscule.
Visits to the local camera store and big box stores were somewhat unrewarding. The local camera shop is filled with pixel peeping snobs, and the big box stores are unable to comprehend the requirements for the field of macrophotography.
The whys of Canon were relatively simple. The primary requirement was to have live view aperature reflected changes. This was evidently not true with Nikon cameras. The viewfinder will largely not be used in a macro world, at least not for this old bird. Far better to accommodate a comfortable body position and let the tools work for us. So the requirements become:
Live View with Aperature Control
Flip LCD screen
Ability to be used by DSLR Controller
www.dslrcontroller.com. This way, once the camera is mounted on the tripod, moved into position, theoretically the rest can be controlled from my Nexus tablet. This remains to be seen, but things that don't work can always be returned. Since cost was a factor in the proof of concept stage, the relative bottom of the line in terms of being fairly current became self evident.
There's a lot of information to be learned, reviewed, and implemented. While waiting for the package arrival, I've tested lots of free focus stacking software, such as EnfuseGUI, DeepSkyStacker, and CombineZP. These can be evaluated using existing hardware as I continue to wait for the package arrival. My resolve for a solution that can accommodate a reasonable posture strong.
Interested in hearing input from others on Tripods, however, I've narrowed this choice down to Vanguard 263AT, Oben 2350, and one or two others. Since the macro rig will not be traveling with me, the option of having a lateral arm is more important than the weight factor. I will sacrifice the 2 lbs weight difference for the cost, which is close to $100 per lb difference in the Aluminum vs. Carbon Fiber class of same tripod functionality.
Thanks and props to this group at the Close Up Project :
thecloseupproject.com, who provide a continual stream of information and practical macro advice.